Easy Homemade Roasted Tomato Sauce: A Rustic 5-Ingredient Recipe for Ultimate Flavor

There’s nothing quite like the rich, comforting aroma of homemade tomato sauce simmering gently. This simple, rustic recipe relies on just five core ingredients, transforming fresh, ripe tomatoes into a luscious sauce perfect for pasta, lasagna, eggplant parmesan, or even as a delightful dip. Prepare to elevate your culinary creations with a sauce that truly tastes like home.

Finding Comfort and Flavor in the Kitchen

Life can throw unexpected challenges our way, and sometimes, the most profound healing comes from the simplest acts – like cooking. After a period of much-needed quiet reflection and recovery, I’m slowly but surely getting back into the rhythm of the kitchen. The incredible outpouring of support during that difficult time, especially in the wake of the hurricane that impacted Houston, was truly humbling. Thank you to everyone who reached out; your kindness meant the world.

Now, it’s time to let food work its magic. The glorious aromas of slow-roasted tomatoes and fragrant garlic have a remarkable way of soothing the soul and gently coaxing one back to a sense of normalcy. It’s amazing how something as fundamental as cooking can be so deeply therapeutic, helping to put one foot in front of the other until it feels as natural as breathing.

As summer fades into fall, fresh tomatoes are in abundant supply. They’re overflowing at farmers markets, gracing grocery store shelves, and for those with a natural green thumb (a talent I confess I lack!), your gardens are likely bursting with juicy, vine-ripened beauties. This seasonal bounty presents the perfect opportunity to make a big batch of homemade roasted tomato sauce.

Using up 4-5 pounds of fresh tomatoes at once ensures you capture their peak flavor. The best part? This homemade sauce is incredibly freezer-friendly, allowing you to savor the taste of summer sunshine all winter long. Imagine pulling out a container of this vibrant, wholesome sauce on a chilly evening – pure culinary bliss!

The Undeniable Advantage of Homemade Tomato Sauce

Just take a moment to admire that luscious, beautiful texture! When you make tomato sauce from scratch, you’re in complete control. You dictate the consistency, the depth of flavor, and exactly what goes into it – no artificial preservatives, no excessive sugar, just pure, wholesome goodness. This recipe celebrates simplicity, proving that incredible flavor doesn’t require a long list of exotic ingredients or complicated steps.

The Quintessential 5 Ingredients You Need

This recipe truly is as easy as it gets, relying on just five fundamental ingredients to create a deeply flavorful and authentic sauce. Let’s count them:

Fresh Tomatoes: The star of the show!
Good Quality Olive Oil: For rich flavor and perfect roasting.
Whole Garlic Cloves: Roasting transforms them into sweet, mellow jewels.
Fresh Basil: Essential for that classic Italian-inspired aroma and taste.
Salt & Pepper: The indispensable seasonings that bring out all the natural flavors.

Okay, if you’re going to get super technical, salt and pepper are two separate ingredients, making it six. But in the spirit of simplicity, they go hand-in-hand! These core ingredients are all you truly need to create a magnificent sauce.

Elevating Your Sauce: Optional Add-ins and Customizations

While the basic 5-ingredient recipe is sublime on its own, you can easily amplify the flavors and adapt it to your taste preferences. Here are a few ideas:

A Hint of Heat: Stir in a generous pinch of red pepper flakes during the blending stage to create a spicy arrabbiata-style sauce that adds a delightful kick.
Herbaceous Depth: A tablespoon of homemade pesto swirled in at the end can add an incredible layer of fresh, vibrant herbaceousness and a touch of creaminess.
Rich & Creamy Texture: For an undeniably rich and creamy texture without adding dairy, consider blending in a handful of pine nuts. They lend a subtle nutty flavor and luxurious mouthfeel.
Sweetness and Body: Roasting large wedges of onion or a few chunks of carrot alongside your tomatoes adds natural sweetness and a deeper, more complex base for your sauce. This is a fantastic trick for sneaking in extra veggies and forms the base for many delicious soups!

The Art of Roasting: Unlocking Deep Tomato Flavor

The secret to this exceptional sauce lies in the slow roasting process. This step concentrates the natural sugars in the tomatoes and garlic, leading to an incredibly rich, sweet, and complex flavor profile that simply can’t be achieved by simmering alone.

Prep Your Tomatoes for Roasting

You have two main options when preparing your tomatoes for roasting:

Slice Them Down the Middle: Halving your tomatoes gives them a greater surface area to char slightly, developing a deeper, more rustic, and intensely flavorful profile. This method often results in a sauce with a slightly more orangey-red hue.
Leave Them Whole: Roasting tomatoes whole, especially smaller varieties like grape or cherry tomatoes, will result in a sauce with a more dazzling, vibrant red color and a slightly less ‘roasted’ flavor.

There’s no wrong choice here; both methods yield delicious results. However, I personally lean towards slicing them for that extra char and rustic appeal.

The Roasting Process

Begin with 4 1/2 to 5 pounds of ripe tomatoes and a generous handful of whole garlic cloves. Crucially, leave the inner papery skin on the garlic cloves; this allows the garlic to steam inside, softening and sweetening without burning. Spread the tomatoes and garlic evenly across two rimmed baking sheets.

Drizzle a good few glugs (about 1/3 cup) of quality olive oil over everything, followed by a generous pinch of salt and freshly ground black pepper. Use your hands to gently massage the tomatoes and garlic, ensuring they are thoroughly coated in the oil and seasonings. This step is vital for even roasting and flavor distribution.

Now, pop the baking sheets into a preheated oven at 300ºF (150ºC) and prepare for your kitchen to be transformed. Over the next three hours, the sweet, oven-ripened smells of garlic and tomato will consume your home, creating an atmosphere of warmth and anticipation. Remember to give the tomatoes and garlic a gentle toss every 30-45 minutes to ensure they roast evenly and don’t stick.

The tomatoes are perfectly done when they have visibly shrunk in size, their skins have burst, and they are tender and slightly caramelized.

From Roast to Sauce: Blending and Finishing

Once your roasted tomatoes and garlic are beautifully tender and fragrant, remove them from the oven. Allow the garlic cloves to cool just enough so they are easy to handle, then peel off their outer covers. The roasted garlic inside will be soft, sweet, and easily mashable – a true flavor powerhouse.

Transfer all the roasted tomatoes and peeled garlic into a blender or food processor. Add a few sprigs of fresh basil. Now, it’s time to give it a whirl! I personally prefer my homemade tomato sauce on the smoother side, so I let the blender run for a little while until it reaches a velvety consistency. If you enjoy a chunkier sauce, simply use the pulse button until it reaches your desired texture.

Taste and Adjust for Perfection

This is arguably the most crucial step! Depending on the natural tartness of your tomatoes and your intended use for the sauce, you might want to balance the flavors. A teaspoon or two of sugar can work wonders in mellowing any acidity and enhancing the overall sweetness. Taste the sauce, and don’t be afraid to adjust. Perhaps a little more salt, another dash of pepper, or even a tiny splash of balsamic vinegar could be what it needs. Remember, no one can make it as perfectly tailored to your palate as you can!

Beyond Pasta: Incredible Ways to Enjoy Your Homemade Roasted Tomato Sauce

This simple 5-ingredient tomato sauce is incredibly versatile. It’s truly a feel-good food that serves as the perfect foundation for countless delicious meals. Here are some of my absolute favorite ways to use it:

The Heart of Lasagna: Imagine a lasagna made entirely from scratch, with this rich, robust sauce at its core. It’s a game-changer!
Simple Weeknight Pasta: Toss it with your favorite pasta for a quick, elegant, and deeply satisfying weeknight meal. Add a sprinkle of Parmesan and fresh basil.
Eggplant Parmesan: Elevate this classic comfort dish with a sauce that truly shines. The rustic flavor pairs beautifully with tender eggplant.
Dip for Mozzarella Sticks: Forget store-bought marinara! This homemade sauce makes an irresistible dipping companion for crispy mozzarella sticks.
Simmered with Meatballs: Let this sauce simmer slowly with your favorite meatballs in a crockpot or on the stove for an incredibly tender and flavorful dish, perfect for football season or any cozy gathering.
Low-Carb Chicken Parmesan: Use it as a vibrant base for healthy twists on classics, like this walnut-crusted chicken parm with zoodles.
Quick Mozzarella Chicken: Combine it with cooked chicken to whip up this delicious 30-minute mozzarella chicken in a flash!
Homemade Pizza Perfection: Spread a generous layer of this flavorful sauce on your homemade pizza crust for a taste that rivals any pizzeria.
Dip for Grilled Cheese: Transform a simple basil and mozzarella grilled cheese sandwich into something special by serving this sauce alongside it for dipping.
Creamless Tomato Basil Soup: Turn it into a wonderfully rich and comforting creamless tomato basil soup – the roasted flavors are incredible!

The possibilities are truly endless with such a simple yet powerfully flavorful base.

Storage and Preservation

This homemade roasted tomato sauce is excellent for meal prepping. Store any leftover sauce in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to one week. For longer preservation, this sauce freezes beautifully. Simply portion it into freezer-safe containers or bags and freeze for up to three months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator or gently reheat from frozen when you’re ready to use it.

P.S. While I know this sauce would be fantastic for canning, I confess I know absolutely nothing about the process! So, if there are any canning experts reading this, please share your wisdom in the comments below. We’d all love to learn your magical ways to preserve this deliciousness!

Yield: approximately 32 ounces of sauce

Simple 5 Ingredient Tomato Sauce

Prep Time
10 minutes

Cook Time
3 hours

Total Time
3 hours 10 minutes

This homemade roasted tomato sauce is crafted with just 5 simple ingredients, offering a rustic and deeply flavorful base for countless dishes. Perfect for pasta, lasagna, and eggplant parmesan.

Simple 5 Ingredient Roasted Tomato Sauce

Ingredients

4 1/2 – 5 pounds of ripe tomatoes (use a variety for complex flavor!)
7-14 whole garlic cloves (with the inner papery skin on)
1/3 cup quality olive oil
Generous pinch of salt and freshly ground pepper
A few sprigs of fresh basil (about 1/4 cup loosely packed leaves)

Optional add-ins for enhanced flavor:

1-3 teaspoons sugar (to balance acidity)
Pinch of red pepper flakes (for a subtle heat)
1 medium onion, cut into large wedges, or 1-2 carrots, cut into 3-4 pieces (for roasting with tomatoes)
1 tablespoon homemade basil pesto or homemade sun-dried tomato pesto

Instructions

Prepare for Roasting: Position two racks in the center of your oven and preheat the oven to 300ºF (150ºC).
Roast Tomatoes & Garlic: Decide how you want to prepare your tomatoes: cut them down the center if you prefer a more charred and rich flavor (which may result in a slightly orange sauce), or leave them whole for a more vibrant red sauce. For smaller grape or cherry tomatoes, leaving them whole is recommended. Add the prepared tomatoes and the whole garlic cloves (with skin on) onto two large, rimmed baking sheets. Drizzle the olive oil evenly over the top and season generously with salt and pepper. Use your hands to gently massage the tomatoes and garlic, ensuring they are thoroughly coated. Roast in the oven for 3 hours, stopping every 30-45 minutes to give them a gentle toss for even roasting. The tomatoes are done when they start to burst, shrink in size, and appear tender and slightly caramelized. Remove trays from the oven and let cool slightly.
Blend the Sauce: Once cooled enough to handle, peel the skin off the roasted garlic cloves (they should be very soft). Transfer all the roasted tomatoes, peeled garlic, and fresh basil sprigs into a blender or food processor. At this point, you can customize further! For a spicier arrabbiata style, toss in a big pinch of red pepper flakes. Adding homemade pesto also works wonderfully for extra herbaceousness. For a chunkier sauce, use the pulse button until the sauce reaches your desired consistency. If you prefer a smooth sauce, let it blend until velvety. Taste the sauce and adjust seasonings; if it’s too tart, add 1-3 teaspoons of sugar to balance the flavors. Leftover sauce can be kept for 1 week in the refrigerator or frozen in airtight containers for up to 3 months.

Notes

Adding More Veggies: If you plan on incorporating onions or carrots, cut the onions into large wedges and the carrots into 3-4 pieces. Roast them on the same baking sheets with the tomatoes and garlic. This is a fantastic way to sneak in additional veggies and adds a layer of subtle sweetness and depth to the sauce. This technique forms the flavorful base for my secret ingredient tomato basil soup!

Have you made this recipe?

If you enjoyed this recipe, please consider leaving a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating and a comment below. You can also share a picture on Instagram with the hashtag #LITTLESPICEJAR, I’d love to see what you made!